2025 Oscars: “Dune 2” Wins & the Controversial Snub

“Dune: Part Two” officially won several Oscars, but these victories only highlighted the ongoing disappointment regarding director Denis Villeneuve’s previous snubbing. Given the acclaim and success of the sci-fi sequel, there was significant anticipation that Villeneuve would receive a nomination for Best Director at the 2025 Oscars, especially since the film competed in multiple categories. Despite the optimism, many hoped he would be nominated among the five finalists, particularly after Dune star Josh Brolin expressed that he would consider retiring from acting if Villeneuve were overlooked again at the 2025 Oscars.

Ultimately, “Dune: Part Two” garnered five nominations for the 97th Academy Awards. However, there was disappointment when Denis Villeneuve was again overlooked for a nomination for Best Director, just as he was for the first film. The nominees in this category were certainly deserving, featuring bold choices like Coralie Fargeat for “The Substance.” Nevertheless, this sparked a strong outcry in support of Villeneuve, who was widely regarded as the biggest snub of the year. Even after Sean Baker’s Best Director win at the 2025 Oscars, the discussion surrounding this situation remains relevant.

Although the Oscars did not have the opportunity to directly recognize Denis Villeneuve’s work as a director, the film’s wins elsewhere served to acknowledge his contributions. This included the acceptance speech for Best Sound, during which Gareth John, Richard King, and Ron Bartlett took the stage to thank various individuals. John used his time to specifically mention Denis Villeneuve, urging everyone in attendance to do the same. He referred to Villeneuve as “the best director you could ever work for.”

This moment proved to be significant for the Oscars, as they honored the work of Denis Villeneuve in “Dune: Part Two.” John encouraged everyone to applaud the director, and the audience complied, allowing the broadcast to cut to Villeneuve sitting in the crowd. While it may not be an Oscar, this recognition holds great value, providing Hollywood with a chance to celebrate Villeneuve in a public setting. Based on his reaction, it was clear that the filmmaker greatly appreciated this moment, especially because it was unprompted.

It’s noteworthy that Gareth John and others take time during their Oscars acceptance speeches to specifically acknowledge Denis Villeneuve. While many Oscar winners mention their directors, calling Villeneuve “the best director you could ever work for” goes a step further. This statement reflects the admiration and respect from everyone who has worked with Villeneuve, highlighting the hard work he puts in and his deservingness of recognition at the highest levels of Hollywood, such as the Oscars. Perhaps this will change in the future.